Report an Insurance Claim After Hours or Directly

For prompt claims service, we highly recommend you call your particular carrier directly.
The phone numbers for 24-hour claims offices are listed below. If for some reason you
cannot make contact, please feel free to use the form below to report a claim to our office,
and we will make contact for you.

Company Claim Phone Numbers

Personal Lines  
Electric Insurance Company 866-424-6201
Farmers Insurance Company 800-435-7764
Foremost Insurance Company 800-527-3907
Indiana Insurance Company 800-279-7221
Kemper Insurance Company 888-252-2799
Ohio Casualty Insurance Company 800-366-6446
Progressive Insurance Company 800-776-7437
Safeco Insurance Company 800-332-3226
State Auto Insurance Company 800-766-1853
Travelers Insurance Company 800-252-4633
Commercial Lines  
American Country Insurance Company 800-818-4848
Gateway Insurance Company 800-593-1333
Indiana Insurance Company 800-279-7221
Ohio Casualty Insurance Company 800-366-6446
Safeco Insurance Company 800-332-3226
Secura Insurance Company 800-233-2345
State Auto Insurance Company 800-766-1853
Travelers Insurance Company 800-832-7839
Zurich Insurance Company 800-987-3373
Life & Health  
Anthem 888-650-4047
CHA 800-457-5683
Humana 800-872-7207


If you are unable to contact the insurance carrier, please call us at 1-800-295-1897 Monday - Friday, 8:15am ñ 4:45pm, or Email us at info.kielyhines.com.